Last updated on March 23rd, 2020 by Erica Garza

As a small business owner, you can probably relate to the expression, “Fortune favors the bold.” But are you applying this maxim to your email communication strategy? The fact is, billions of dollars in potential sales never happen each year — simply because many of us aren’t bold enough to send a simple follow-up email. Or, if we are courageous enough, we write our follow-ups in the wrong way, and don’t get the results we’re looking for.

In this guide, we’ll show you how to write a follow-up email the right way, so you don’t miss out on a valuable sale or client relationship.

But Do Follow-Up Messages Even Work?

Before we describe how to write a follow-up message, it’s important to explain that follow-ups actually work. In fact, Woodpecker.co says that “a campaign with so many as one follow-up converts about 22 percent more prospects than the one without any.”

Countless sources agree with this notion that follow-up emails are essential for converting leads. For example, a study from Iko-Systems.com found that their consecutive emails benefited from the following response pattern:

  • First email: 18 percent response rate
  • Second email: 14 percent response rate
  • Third email: 12 percent response rate
  • Fourth email: 13 percent response rate
  • Fifth email: 10 percent response rate
  • Sixth email: 27 percent response rate

Isn’t it interesting that the response rate didn’t significantly decline with the consecutive emails in the Iko-Systems study? And isn’t it even more surprising that the sixth email received a sharp spike in responses, from 10 percent to 27 percent?

Another study from Yesware.com offers more proof that follow-up messages are important: “According to Yesware’s data, if you don’t receive a reply to your first email, you have a 21 percent chance of getting a reply to the second one. Still no reply? Take heart and keep sending: There’s still a 25 percent chance that you will eventually hear back from the recipient.”

Based on these statistics, it clearly pays to send multiple follow-ups in response to a no-response. But how do you craft a follow-up message in a way that gets results?

Tips for Writing Successful Follow-Up Emails

While the most important piece of advice is to simply be “bold” enough to send a follow-up email in the first place, there are a few core strategies to apply to your follow-up messages in terms of content and timing. Adhering to these tips will boost the success of your follow-up emails:

  • Timing Your Follow-Ups: For the 18 percent who do reply to your first message, most will do it on the same day. Therefore, when you don’t receive a same-day response, it’s likely you’re never going to hear from them. The general rule of thumb is to wait two to three days after a no-response to send your follow-up message. For the second email, extend the wait time to four days, then seven days, then two weeks and finally, schedule follow-ups on a monthly basis.
  • Stay Consistent With Your Email Timing and Content: Once you have a system in place for timing your follow-up emails, stick with it and track the results. In time, you may choose to tweak your email timing strategy, and you’ll have plenty of past statistics to know if the new strategy works. Similarly, stay consistent with the wording in your follow-ups. Make sure you fully test new follow-up templates before discarding old ones — and always reuse what works.
  • Understand Your Goals: If you don’t get the right results from your follow-up messages, it could be a sign that you haven’t clarified your communication goals. For example, are you trying to make a sale, schedule an in-person meeting, arrange a phone call, get more information, or do you have another kind of goal? Understanding your goals and communicating them in your emails will improve your results.
  • Explain Yourself: As your pitches become clearer, more succinct and relatable, your email response rates will increase.
  • Know Your Customer: Getting to know your customer will also boost follow-up email success. As you know your prospects better, you’ll get to know the phrasing, sentiment and approaches they relate to, and that will help you get better results with your communication efforts.
  • Don’t Forget the Call to Action: Sometimes, the reason follow-up emails fail is that you haven’t told your clients what to do. Every email should end with a simple call to action. Tell your client exactly what you want him or her to do in plain English, and there’s a better chance your client will follow the request.

Try Titan

As a business owner, you need to focus on your company — not managing the backend of your email platform. With Titan, setting up multiple business email accounts is simple, fast, and requires zero technical know-how. 

Try Titan for free and see how your business can benefit from supercharged, automated email without the technical overhead!

  • Follow-Up Email
Originally published 6th February 2020 12:43:00am, last updated on March 23rd, 2020

Get more insight and tips for building your brand with business email.
Straight to your inbox.


More from Titan

Business Email

Small businesses need email. But not just any email, they need business email. Why? Because it's hard to look credible when your work email ends in @gmail.com or @yahoo.com.

Email Templates

If done right, email can be a small business's most impactful tool. Follow these email best practices and use these free email templates to power your business.

Professionalism

Regardless of what you do and where you do it, the online presence of your business needs to convey credibility.

Your Business

You know you need to get your business online, but it's overwhelming. Have no fear, Titan will guide you through everything you should and shouldn't do.

More from Titan

Business Email

Every professional outlet needs business email –– that's email with an address that matches their domain and a service that's secure and provides business-friendly features. With the never-ending deluge of spam, phishing, and other scams carried out over email, the world has grown weary of businesses that use @gmail.com and @yahoo.com addresses. The Titan blog is committed to conveying the importance of business email. Check out these articles for a closer look at business email fundamentals and best practices.

Email Templates

How much time do you spend writing emails? Emails take up a lot of time for small business owners because they matter. One email might be the only chance you have to interact with a customer. But who has the time to craft the perfect email for every outreach? That's why the Titan blog has committed to providing our readers with the most useful email templates for their business. Whether you're looking to announce your new business, recruit talent, send a cold email to a prospect, or request a review, we've got you covered!

Professionalism

The seed for your new business has been planted and now that it's starting to sprout, you know you need to build it out online. But as a small business owner, you don't have a web developer and marketer to help you craft a professional digital presence. But don't fret. Building a professional image online is not nearly as hard or as pricey as it used to be. Check out these blogs to learn how your business can effectively and affordably level the playing field with its biggest competitors in the digital economy.

Your Business

Regardless of what you do and where you do it, the online presence of your business needs to convey credibility. The way you communicate with and present yourself to customers impacts every aspect of your business. But when it comes to establishing digital credibility, it's the small things, like a business email address, that often get overlooked. The Titan blog is here to help. Check out these blogs to learn how to effectively separate your business from the amateurism that plagues many small businesses online.

Get down to business with the professional email you deserve.

Get started for free